Sunday, September 13, 2015

List of Posts on the Clinical Trials included by SFA vs. PUFA Meta-Analyses

In the following table I have listed the clinical trials included in meta-analyses related to saturated fat and/or polyunsaturated fat and the incidence of coronary heart disease.  The table lists which the trials included by the meta-analyses and how they are categorised in Ramsden et al (2010) and Hooper et al (2012)*.  I have also added hyperlinks to the blog posts on the trials.  Due to size constraints in the table I abbreviated the meta-analyses as follows:

H12     Hooper et al (2012)
Har      Harcombe et al (2015)
H15     Hooper et al (2015)

* Ramsden et al categorised trials as replacing SFA with just n-6 PUFA (6) or with both n-6 and n-3 PUFA (6+3).  Hooper et al (2012) categorised trials as involving fat modification (M) or both modifications and reductions in fat (M,R).  For the National Diet Heart Study Hooper et al (2012) drew several comparisons between the experimental and control groups in the first and second studies.  Some of the experimental diets were modified fat while others were both modified and reduced fat and were categorised accordingly (Both)



SM
Moz
Ram
H12
Cho
SH
Har
H15
X


X
(6)
X
(M)

X
X
X







X

X
X
X
(6+3)
X
(M)
X
X
X
X




X
(Both)




X
X
X
(6+3)
X
(M)
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
(6+3)
X
(M)
X


X
X
X
X


X






X
(6)
X
(M)
X
X
X
X



X
(M)




X
X
X
X
(6)
X
(M)
X




X
X

X
(M,R)
X
X


X
X
X
X
(6+3)
X
(M,R)
X
X


X








X








X



X
(M,R)













X








X







X



X
(M,R)




No comments:

Post a Comment